|
Post by boraddict on Mar 22, 2021 18:41:38 GMT -6
from GotQuestions:
(Emphasis added.)
Thanks Natalie. One problem with the article is that 2 Kings 17:24 is not about Jews but transplanted people into the land of the Ephraimites. So if there was any intermarrying in Samaria then it was not to those of Judah but Ephraim; thus the article is incorrect on this point. Secondly, Ezra 4:2-11 is like many years later and after Babylon had taken Judah. So the author of the article has the taking of the northern kingdom by the Assyrians intertwined with the taking of the southern kingdom by the Babylonians many years later. Big mistake. For me, if an author tends to call the northern tribes Judah, then they have already lost the debate.
|
|
|
Post by boraddict on Mar 22, 2021 19:07:51 GMT -6
boraddict, not that I want to be rude and mix in with your beautiful discussion, as I am a mostly quiet member here, but... practically your entire argument is based on the conjecture that the two sticks are representative for the OT and NT. Problem is, there is no biblical basis for this, it's just an idea. Nowhere near enough to base a solid teaching on. Also, if all the nation are Ephraim, the whole narrative just doesn't work. The prophet's story, God's story is that of a divided people driven away from their land (in separate events) and returning as one. Christians are neither driven away from the mountains of Israel, nor returning there. It was always "Judah, Israel and the Nations". Christians are from the Nations (except for those who are from the Jews), not from Israel. The Christians' story an entirely different story then the Israelites'. The Israelites' story is about God's punished and scattered people being gathered home, now without Idolatry. The Christians' story, is about humans among all peoples who never had any promise from God in the first place, suddenly given a place in Him, and in His people. We cannot mix these stories up. In fact, rondonmonson's argument is very strong: There is evidence that every tribe is now represented in Israel. One may argue that the prophecy is partly fulfilled by now. They are back. They are one people - the stick is joined. They are no longer Judah and Ephraim, but a united Israel, occupying territory of both tribes. One person rules over all of them, Benjamin Netanyahu. When the prophecy will be entirely fulfilled, then instead of him the Son of David, our Lord Jesus, will rule. Thank you firefrorefiddle, and while your position is very good it does however have a problem with the placement of the Christians. That is, to what tribe in Israel do they belong? And please do not interject that Judah is Israel because history proves that the northern kingdom was Ephraim and the southern kingdom was Judah and they together made up all of Israel. So the argument is that since the northern kingdom was conquered and carried away by Assyria then it no longer exists except as remnants intermixed in Judah; like Benjamin. That being the case then Ephraim that was carried away of whom many survived were all killed off by your calculations. Or, are you saying that those people that also had the bloodline of Judah and Benjamin intermixed within were taken off the earth? I don't think so. No, they were intermixed into some populations and their blood still exists to day. So while it may be the case that the blood of all 12 tribes are in Judah, then the same is true for those taken by the Assyrians and intermixed into other populations. Consequently, Israel has been mixed throughout Asia and perhaps Europe and to that point I do not know. But to say that only Judah has the blood of Israel is just not true because that blood has been intermingled all over the planet. So what tribe are they of, those whom are followers of Christ? Jesus claims everyone as Israel. Your argument is weak on this one point because it does not account for the placement of the followers of Christ that are Israel and not Judah. In fact, the tribe of Judah to this day still rejects the Savior. That leaves the only remaining tribe of authority and that is Ephraim that is called Israel. I do not understand why so many call Judah, Israel. It must be a doctrine that is taught in the churches.
|
|
|
Post by Natalie on Mar 22, 2021 21:03:43 GMT -6
boraddict , where in Scripture do you see that Christians become one of the twelve tribes? (Scripture only, not an assumption based on an interpretation) If true, how does a Christian know what tribe they are of? My thought is that a Christian only becomes part of one of the tribes if they renounce Christ and embrace Judaism. (Similar issues are addressed in the book of Hebrews) Or they are genetically a descendent of Jacob and have become a Christian (Messianic Jew). I think where we have a disconnect is that you consider Jews only of Judah where many people (and churches) consider all descendants of Jacob to be Jews. They could also called Hebrews or Israelites or children of Jacob or physical descendants of Abraham. Christians are descendants of Abraham by faith - Jews are descendants by blood. To be in the twelve tribes a person would have to be a blood descendent (or a convert to Judaism).
|
|
|
Post by Natalie on Mar 22, 2021 21:12:05 GMT -6
Another thought...Jesus calls all Israel because He came to the descendants of Jacob who He had renamed Israel back in Genesis when He wrestled with Jacob. Jesus did not come to the Gentiles although His Gospel would go to them. The truth of the Church was a later revelation when the majority of Israel rejected their Messiah.
|
|
|
Post by boraddict on Mar 22, 2021 23:32:09 GMT -6
boraddict , where in Scripture do you see that Christians become one of the twelve tribes? (Scripture only, not an assumption based on an interpretation) If true, how does a Christian know what tribe they are of? My thought is that a Christian only becomes part of one of the tribes if they renounce Christ and embrace Judaism. (Similar issues are addressed in the book of Hebrews) Or they are genetically a descendent of Jacob and have become a Christian (Messianic Jew). I think where we have a disconnect is that you consider Jews only of Judah where many people (and churches) consider all descendants of Jacob to be Jews. They could also called Hebrews or Israelites or children of Jacob or physical descendants of Abraham. Christians are descendants of Abraham by faith - Jews are descendants by blood. To be in the twelve tribes a person would have to be a blood descendent (or a convert to Judaism). Thank you Natalie , and you are at the very heart of the issue. So let's say that God in the beginning gave the law and this law included that Jesus is the Christ. Because, God knew that man could not live the law and needed a Savior. Thus, Jesus was with God from the very beginning. Additionally, those who followed Lord Jesus were written in the book of life. That is, since God sees everything, past, present, and future, then he knows everyone that has salvation and are written in the book of life. That is, all who follow Jesus have salvation from the law of God. Which by the way is perfection because God is perfect and all that comes from him is perfect and such is the requirement for the imperfect people to have salvation from God's law. Because, they can not live the law; because they are not perfect. That is, because of the perfect law then man will sin and needs a Savior from the violations of the law. Because of the critical nature of the need for a Savior then the line of birthright to the culmination of the death of the Savior was shared with man. Thus, Jesus would be born through a line of great patriarchs beginning with Adam and down through Noah to Abraham, then to Isaac, and Jacob, and through Judah. This birthright line was however not dependent upon an earthly father but an earthly mother and we all know this. In other words, the Savior's mother would create him here upon the earth as all children are created. So, the line of birth from father to son ends at Jesus' mother's father because she is a woman. In other words, it was not the men that played the critical role in the Savior's creation here upon the earth but they pointed to his creation via a line of patriarchs the last of which was Jacob and then through the line of Judah. That is, the line from Adam to the Savior goes through Judah and his children; and two examples of this is given in the NT. And, something that should be already understood and I will go ahead and say is that Jesus' Father is God. That is, the father to son down line ends at Mary's (Jesus' mother) father who was of the line of Judah. This does not include all of the 12 tribes of Israel but Judah only. So, Judah is the birthright line of the King of the earth. Not any of the other tribes, but Judah only. Along with the birthright line to the Savior that is Judah are the other tribes born to Israel (Jacob). These would participate in claiming to the world that Jesus is the Christ. The manner in which they play this part is through Ephraim that all who are born into the house of Israel are in Ephraim. Because, they profess the Savior that is Lord Jesus to the world; they are the Christians. That is, all Christians are in the house of Israel via Ephraim; not Judah. In other words, the 12 tribes of Israel are constituted within the Christian movement. And, even if there is no actual blood of Jacob running through the veins of a person; if said person accepts Christ then they are in Israel via Ephraim; not Judah. That is, the birthright tribe (Judah) has a special place and some day they will accept the Savior. But until that time then they stand alone as the chosen people whom are of the birthright tribe. When they convert then they no longer are designated as Jews but Christians. And, although they are of the birthright tribe they are also of Ephraim that testifies to the world of Christ. In other words, Ephraim is Christian and visa versa. Secondly, Ephraim includes all twelve tribes of Israel that testify of Christ. That is, Israel that is Ephraim are the Christians; and Judah that are the Jews are the birthright tribe. Today the Christians (Ephraim) will not convert to Judaism and the Jews reject Christ. I hope that I have not included any contradictions in the above wording and may need to do another edit. The blessing from Jacob to Ephraim, his son via adoption from Joseph (Gen 48:5-6), was that he (Ephraim) would be a multitude of nations (Gen. 48:19) and that Israel's name is upon him and his brother (Gen. 48:16). Then Jacob blessed his sons to tell them what would befall them in the last days (Gen. 49:1). And here is the blessing upon Joseph (Gen. 49:22-26). Please notice that Joseph has the blessing of procreation unto the everlasting hills. And this is here in the last days. The everlasting hills are the everlasting nations of Ephraim, the birthright son of Joseph. Post Script: Please consider the 12 tribes of Israel as stated in Rev. 7:5-8. Both Manasseh and Joseph are listed in the group of 12 meaning that Joseph is being used to represent Ephraim in the list. Right, Manasseh and Joseph are Manasseh and Ephraim; the two sons of Joseph that were adopted into the house of Israel. They both are the tribes of adoption but Ephraim has that birthright blessing. So not only was Ephraim adopted but he also adopts all other tribes into his family. Such is the case for the Christians; they are brought into the family of Israel via Ephraim under the law of adoption. Joseph has greater blessing than all the other tribes (Gen. 49:26). Jacob is saying that his (Jacob's) blessings were greater than his father's and now his (Jacob') blessings go to Joseph. In other words, Jacob has transferred his blessing to Joseph. As a result, Ephraim having the birthright blessing from Jacob now has the position as the head of the family and the tribes of Israel are the tribes of Ephraim.
|
|
rondonmonson
Truth Seeker
I can do all things through Christ which strengthens me....
Posts: 186
|
Post by rondonmonson on Mar 23, 2021 9:33:00 GMT -6
rondonmonson , There is truth here brother. i'm curious about this though. "All 12 tribes now live in Israel sister." You mean this in a geographic sense or in a broader sense? Geographical of course, they all got lost in the Judean Culture long ago, but God knows who they are. He knows every Jew that is a Levite, every Jew that is from the tribe of Asher or from the tribe of Gad. Though we call them all Jews as in they are all Judean, God knows better. In other words they all became ONE STICK as a single nation of Israel, but all 12 tribes are living in Israel as Jews as we speak.
|
|
rondonmonson
Truth Seeker
I can do all things through Christ which strengthens me....
Posts: 186
|
Post by rondonmonson on Mar 23, 2021 9:47:36 GMT -6
Love the post Ron and have just come to (somewhat) understand the tribes issue recently myself...This is the part you wrote that glares so bright with me rondonmonson said: Prov 12:15, Prov 16:25, Prov 30:12, Psa 62:4 And what does this all lead to brother? (rhetorical-however I do want to hear your view or addition...) It leads to Romans 1! How I sum up this chapter to people who do not understand the Word or better do not read it you want it this way (homosexuality, abortion, coveting lies abhorring truth...) God allows it and promotes it for you. Here you go, I (God) give you over to your carnal, ungodly hearts/desires. The trials of the Israelites is littered with this (2Chron 18:22 / 1Kings 22:23). They go after false gods, often trying to mingle the false religion with truth, trusting in those things which are abominable! (Isa 46), which does not mix (Dan 2) EDIT - the Romans 1 mindset applies not only to those who are given over but to the harlot church! Itching ears O personally see the Harlot as ALL FALSE RELIGION of All Time. In other words Islam today is the largest part of the Harlot, Buddhism, Hinduism and even the Mormons (cough, cough), but it goes back much further, of course, the Egyptians, Babylonian, Romans, Greeks all served False gods, those inhabitants of Cannan served Baal, which became Bel then Belios then Zeus then Jupiter. Its all the same false god, Satan. Nowadays Satan is attacking in a different way, he is getting people to believe there is NOTHING BUT MANKIND, thus the last false god will be a man !! He is angling them towards worshiping a great man as god, whereas before it was always a false god built of wood, rock, gold, silver etc. You see brother, they have to accept their sins as Romans 1 says as being NO SINS else they need to repent and are thus in need of cleansing, thus they need to accept all manner of evil as natural lifestyles. The only pervert people in their minds are those that refuse to accept these perversions as pur and legitimate lifestyles, else they need to be CLEANSED, and they do not admit to being sinners, they are PURE and RIGHTEOUS people, thus if they have to lie to win an election, so be it, if they have to cheat to win polls and thus indoctrinate people, so be it. They see evil as all those who refuse to accept perverted lifestyles as normal. They do not understand that NO ORDER leads to CHAOS.
|
|
|
Post by lionofgod on Mar 23, 2021 13:23:08 GMT -6
rondonmonson , There is truth here brother. i'm curious about this though. "All 12 tribes now live in Israel sister." You mean this in a geographic sense or in a broader sense? Geographical of course, they all got lost in the Judean Culture long ago, but God knows who they are. He knows every Jew that is a Levite, every Jew that is from the tribe of Asher or from the tribe of Gad. Though we call them all Jews as in they are all Judean, God knows better. In other words they all became ONE STICK as a single nation of Israel, but all 12 tribes are living in Israel as Jews as we speak. So your assertion is that all of the remainder of the 12 tribes of Israel are now all residing within the country of Israel it's self? Meaning all Jews not already in the state of Israel, residing at this moment, are not of the tribes of Israel? This is why I asked my question. "Of course" implies I ought assume something, which bodes ill most oft. I thought perhaps you meant they are "represented" their now, but sought clarification on your intent of word.
|
|
|
Post by Natalie on Mar 23, 2021 17:32:36 GMT -6
boraddict , but you did not include Scripture that shows Christians become one of the tribes. You show Scripture based on your conclusion that Christians are Ephraim.
To me it seems that you are making assumptions and interpretations based on what Israel (as a whole) was supposed to do - proclaim God to all nations, and as an extension, accept the Savior and proclaim Him. It seems that because only Christians are doing this, you make them Ephraim.
Yes, we are adopted as sons (and daughters) of God when we place our faith in Christ. But we (Gentiles) are the sheep of the other pasture John 10:16. Yes, it says that we join the Jews that accepted Him but it doesn't say we become part of national Israel or that we become Ephraim. If anything it just suggests we become one group, which today we call the Church.
This verse was brought up Sunday:
Galatians 6:16 - And as for all who walk by this rule, peace and mercy be upon them, and upon the Israel of God.
In context - the "them" are Gentile Christians and the "Israel of God" are Jewish Christians. There is a separation, but yet there is also that in Christ we are one, neither Jew or Gentile. But sometimes in writing to believers there was a separation because each group needed to hear something specific.
In Romans, Gentiles are grafted in - we are now connected to the Root (Jesus) but it doesn't mean that we are part of the 12 tribes. We are Gentile believers in Messiah. We gain the spiritual blessings of that promise. The 12 tribes are a national distinction and depend on being a descendant of Jacob (who God renamed Israel).
|
|
|
Post by boraddict on Mar 23, 2021 19:15:24 GMT -6
boraddict , but you did not include Scripture that shows Christians become one of the tribes. You show Scripture based on your conclusion that Christians are Ephraim.
To me it seems that you are making assumptions and interpretations based on what Israel (as a whole) was supposed to do - proclaim God to all nations, and as an extension, accept the Savior and proclaim Him. It seems that because only Christians are doing this, you make them Ephraim.
Yes, we are adopted as sons (and daughters) of God when we place our faith in Christ. But we (Gentiles) are the sheep of the other pasture John 10:16. Yes, it says that we join the Jews that accepted Him but it doesn't say we become part of national Israel or that we become Ephraim. If anything it just suggests we become one group, which today we call the Church.
This verse was brought up Sunday:
Galatians 6:16 - And as for all who walk by this rule, peace and mercy be upon them, and upon the Israel of God.
In context - the "them" are Gentile Christians and the "Israel of God" are Jewish Christians. There is a separation, but yet there is also that in Christ we are one, neither Jew or Gentile. But sometimes in writing to believers there was a separation because each group needed to hear something specific.
In Romans, Gentiles are grafted in - we are now connected to the Root (Jesus) but it doesn't mean that we are part of the 12 tribes. We are Gentile believers in Messiah. We gain the spiritual blessings of that promise. The 12 tribes are a national distinction and depend on being a descendant of Jacob (who God renamed Israel).
Christians do not become one of the tribes of Israel, but they are Israel; all twelve tribes. This is shown in The Book of Revelation wherein the 12 tribes are sealed in Rev. 7:3-8 and standing with Jesus at Rev. 14:1. This shows that these 12 tribes are Christian. Please notice that Judah is only one of the twelve. Like, let's say that we call all 12 tribes Judah then Judah represents one twelfth of Judah. That does not make sense.
|
|
|
Post by Natalie on Mar 24, 2021 8:08:22 GMT -6
A plain reading of Revelation chapter 7 shows believers in Messiah from each of the tribes of national Israel. Yes, that would make them Christians. But they are of the blood lines of Rueben, Gad, Naphtali, etc. God knows who belongs to each tribe.
A couple of days ago there was an article posted in the shoutbox and part of it talked about the preparation of the Levite priests going on in Israel. They have found that those who descended from Levi have a specific genetic marker that no one else has. So, the tribe of Levi is not lost.
Gentiles do not become part of national (physical) Israel. If you want to call them spiritual Israel, I think one can make a case for that. But spiritual Israel is not divided up into tribes. They are one in Christ. There is a distinction between physical Israel (the 12 tribes) and a spiritual Israel.
I still know of no Scripture that says the church becomes Israel or Ephraim.
|
|
rondonmonson
Truth Seeker
I can do all things through Christ which strengthens me....
Posts: 186
|
Post by rondonmonson on Mar 24, 2021 9:28:16 GMT -6
Geographical of course, they all got lost in the Judean Culture long ago, but God knows who they are. He knows every Jew that is a Levite, every Jew that is from the tribe of Asher or from the tribe of Gad. Though we call them all Jews as in they are all Judean, God knows better. In other words they all became ONE STICK as a single nation of Israel, but all 12 tribes are living in Israel as Jews as we speak. So your assertion is that all of the remainder of the 12 tribes of Israel are now all residing within the country of Israel it's self? Meaning all Jews not already in the state of Israel, residing at this moment, are not of the tribes of Israel? This is why I asked my question. "Of course" implies I ought assume something, which bodes ill most oft. I thought perhaps you meant they are "represented" their now, but sought clarification on your intent of word. I didn't quite get the reasoning for that "" Quotation tbh, I kind of assumed you were asking why I would say sister there, so I checked to make sure I was replying to a woman, and I was. Now I understand, you were asking does this just or ONLY mean Israel in general as per all 12 tribes. The answer therefore is no, the tribes were mixed up before the Diaspora, the Assyrians toted the Northern Kingdoms off over 700 years before the 70 AD event took place. So, the 12 tribes were all brought back from foreign nations, so those still in foreign nations also are of all 12 tribes, they are just known as Jews, the Judean Culture became the culture of all the tribes eventually over a period of many years from the time the Assyrians started the deportation in 740 BC to the time they conquered and departed Samaria in 722 BC, to 70 AD the seed of the Northern tribes basically assimilated into the Judean culture over those many, many years. By they time of the Diaspora they were simply all thought of as Jews. (Judeans). What I mean by Geographical of course is I was pointing to all the tribes being in Israel present day. Not SCATTERED all over the world with only the Jews (Judah) being in modern day Israel. Now of course all of those "Jews" scattered all over the word are also really the 12 tribes of Israel also. They have become ONE STICK but ONE STICK of 12 Tribes.
|
|
rondonmonson
Truth Seeker
I can do all things through Christ which strengthens me....
Posts: 186
|
Post by rondonmonson on Mar 24, 2021 10:50:09 GMT -6
A plain reading of Revelation chapter 7 shows believers in Messiah from each of the tribes of national Israel. Yes, that would make them Christians. But they are of the blood lines of Rueben, Gad, Naphtali, etc. God knows who belongs to each tribe. A couple of days ago there was an article posted in the shoutbox and part of it talked about the preparation of the Levite priests going on in Israel. They have found that those who descended from Levi have a specific genetic marker that no one else has. So, the tribe of Levi is not lost. Gentiles do not become part of national (physical) Israel. If you want to call them spiritual Israel, I think one can make a case for that. But spiritual Israel is not divided up into tribes. They are one in Christ. There is a distinction between physical Israel (the 12 tribes) and a spiritual Israel. I still know of no Scripture that says the church becomes Israel or Ephraim. It is true all of us who TAKE ON Christ are called Christians which means Christ like, which really means our goal is via the mercy of God to be Christ-Like. But in truth its really the PROMISE (as you well know) that redeems us to God, the Promise of a coming redeemer to Abraham became fact when Jesus died for our sins. The Law was added 430 years later (after the promise). So ALL those that BELIVE on God become righteous by Faith in the coming Redeemer as in Abraham, Daniel and Ezekiel's cases or like in our cases by believing in the Promised one who came. Either way, it is FAITH in that Redeemer that saves us from our sins. Amen. I only point that out, to point out many peoples fallacy in their understanding Galatians chapter 3, Paul never told anyone that Jews and Gentiles were one and the same, this is a clever wordsmith trick by Satan. His words were pointing out just the opposite point unto the Gentiles, he was saying "Hey, you don't have to be Jews to be of God" that is what he was really saying in Galatians chapter 3, but Satan has a way of twisting things over time to mean something else, if we let him. I will teach it below, it seems you already know this, but a lot of people really think the Church has taken over the mantle of Israel. I don't usually like posting a lot of scriptures, but this is important. This whole teaching goes back to what I was speaking about, FAITH vs THE LAW and the works thereof. It was never about the Gentiles and Jews becoming ONE, it was about the Gentiles understanding they didn't have to be like the Jews to be of God, someone was teaching the Gentiles they had to practice as the Jews did to be of God, Paul says WHO HAS BEWITCHED YOU? Galatians 3:1 O foolish Galatians, who hath bewitched you, that ye should not obey the truth, before whose eyes Jesus Christ hath been evidently set forth, crucified among you? 2 This only would I learn of you, Received ye the Spirit by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith? 3 Are ye so foolish? having begun in the Spirit, are ye now made perfect by the flesh? 4 Have ye suffered so many things in vain? if it be yet in vain. 5 He therefore that ministereth to you the Spirit, and worketh miracles among you, doeth he it by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith? 6 Even as Abraham believed God, and it was accounted to him for righteousness. 7 Know ye therefore that they which are of faith, the same are the children of Abraham. 8 And the scripture, foreseeing that God would justify the heathen through faith, preached before the gospel unto Abraham, saying, In thee shall all nations be blessed. 9 So then they which be of faith are blessed with faithful Abraham. 10 For as many as are of the works of the law are under the curse: for it is written, Cursed is every one that continueth not in all things which are written in the book of the law to do them. 11 But that no man is justified by the law in the sight of God, it is evident: for, The just shall live by faith. {{{ The Galatians has started keeping the Sabbath, keeping the Jewish Laws etc. maybe even sacrificing, and Paul scolds them, WHO HAS BEWITCHED YOU, that starting out via Faith in Christ Jesus you have now moved to WORKS under the Law, so some Jewish Leaders no doubt, who were also "Christian" told them, you can be of God, but you have to keep the Sabbath, and do these Laws, etc. etc. and Paul thus says HOLD UP, what's going on here, who has told you this? Its NONSENSE !! We live by FAITH }}}12 And the law is not of faith: but, The man that doeth them shall live in them. 13 Christ hath redeemed us from the curse of the law, being made a curse for us: for it is written, Cursed is every one that hangeth on a tree: 14 That the blessing of Abraham might come on the Gentiles through Jesus Christ; that we might receive the promise of the Spirit through faith. 15 Brethren, I speak after the manner of men; Though it be but a man's covenant, yet if it be confirmed, no man disannulleth, or addeth thereto. {{{ Paul then explains unto the Galatians how the Law is not of THE FAITH, in order to be justified of the law you have to keep every bit of the law at all times, the law condemns, but never justifies, only FAITH can justify, Faith in the promised Redeemer Jesus Christ. }}}16 Now to Abraham and his seed were the promises made. He saith not, And to seeds, as of many; but as of one, And to thy seed, which is Christ. 17 And this I say, that the covenant, that was confirmed before of God in Christ, the law, which was four hundred and thirty years after, cannot disannul, that it should make the promise of none effect. 18 For if the inheritance be of the law, it is no more of promise: but God gave it to Abraham by promise. 19 Wherefore then serveth the law? It was added because of transgressions, till the seed should come to whom the promise was made; and it was ordained by angels in the hand of a mediator. 20 Now a mediator is not a mediator of one, but God is one. 21 Is the law then against the promises of God? God forbid: for if there had been a law given which could have given life, verily righteousness should have been by the law. 22 But the scripture hath concluded all under sin, that the promise by faith of Jesus Christ might be given to them that believe. 23 But before faith came, we were kept under the law, shut up unto the faith which should afterwards be revealed. 24 Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ, that we might be justified by faith. 25 But after that faith is come, we are no longer under a schoolmaster. 26 For ye are all the children of God by faith in Christ Jesus. 27 For as many of you as have been baptized into Christ have put on Christ. {{{ Paul explains how even Abraham BELIVED God to be justified, and that this LAW they were trusting in was only added 430 years AFTER the Promise was made, thus the original covenant was never THE LAW it was always THE PRIOMISE of the coming seed Jesus Christ. He does tell them the Law is not against the promises of God but that the law only condemns, it can't justify you, only FAITH can justify you. Faith in Jesus Christ the Redeemer. }}}28 There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus. 29 And if ye be Christ's, then are ye Abraham's seed, and heirs according to the promise. {{ There is neither Jew NOR Greek/Gentile is being used by Paul here as an axiom to make a point, he of course is not saying there are no Jews nor Gentiles, just like he is not saying there are no MALES nor FEMALES........Its funny no one ever says males and females have meshed as one because of this scripture, BUT they say there are no longer Jews nor Gentiles and we have all become ONE VIA Faith, that is not what Paul was saying at all, just like he wasn't implying there are no males or females, Paul was making a POINT to the Galatians, telling them, "HEY, you don't have to become Jews to be of God" because in God's eyes ONLY FAITH matters !! Be ye Greeks, Jews, Chinese, Hondurans, Ethiopians etc. etc. etc. But that doesn't mean the Jews and Gentiles have become ONE anymore than it mean Males and Females had become ONE. }}Israel has to repent during the 70th week. After the Rapture of the Church. God treats everyone the same, the proof of this is, there will be Jews AND Gentiles in the Rapture who lived in Christ during the Church Age. There will be Gentile Martyrs who come unto Christ after the Rapture AND the 1/3 of the Jews who come to Jesus also after the Rapture during the 70th week, God will protect them to fulfill His promise to Abraham to have a continual seed on this earth forever. So, all those who come unto God must come by FAITH ALONE, be it before the Rapture or after the Rapture.
|
|
|
Post by lionofgod on Mar 24, 2021 13:50:28 GMT -6
So your assertion is that all of the remainder of the 12 tribes of Israel are now all residing within the country of Israel it's self? Meaning all Jews not already in the state of Israel, residing at this moment, are not of the tribes of Israel? This is why I asked my question. "Of course" implies I ought assume something, which bodes ill most oft. I thought perhaps you meant they are "represented" their now, but sought clarification on your intent of word. I didn't quite get the reasoning for that "" Quotation tbh, I kind of assumed you were asking why I would say sister there, so I checked to make sure I was replying to a woman, and I was. Now I understand, you were asking does this just or ONLY mean Israel in general as per all 12 tribes. The answer therefore is no, the tribes were mixed up before the Diaspora, the Assyrians toted the Northern Kingdoms off over 700 years before the 70 AD event took place. So, the 12 tribes were all brought back from foreign nations, so those still in foreign nations also are of all 12 tribes, they are just known as Jews, the Judean Culture became the culture of all the tribes eventually over a period of many years from the time the Assyrians started the deportation in 740 BC to the time they conquered and departed Samaria in 722 BC, to 70 AD the seed of the Northern tribes basically assimilated into the Judean culture over those many, many years. By they time of the Diaspora they were simply all thought of as Jews. (Judeans). What I mean by Geographical of course is I was pointing to all the tribes being in Israel present day. Not SCATTERED all over the world with only the Jews (Judah) being in modern day Israel. Now of course all of those "Jews" scattered all over the word are also really the 12 tribes of Israel also. They have become ONE STICK but ONE STICK of 12 Tribes. Thanks, thats what I was trying to ascertain. Sorry, I'm trying to proofread, but my typing stinks and my eyesight leaves alot to be desired. LOL So, I often forget to put a closing quotes, my fault. Your answer was concise and complete. My thanks. God Bless
|
|
|
Post by Natalie on Mar 24, 2021 15:10:14 GMT -6
rondonmonson, thanks for your thoughts on Galatians. That's how I see it, too. Gentiles don't have to become Jews to belong to God. I guess that point I was trying to make also is that it is one body of Christ. The Church isn't going to be divided up into 12. If it were the Church shown in Rev 7, then it would mean divisions. Or at least that's how my mind sees it.
|
|