|
Post by mike on Oct 23, 2017 12:30:20 GMT -6
****extracted this and the following 2-3 notes from the "Hearing God" thread**** MikeTaft forgive me for this, perhaps my heart isnt right but I am a little skeptical of "healing" ministries or any Word/Faith type. Todd White in the video gives me reason for caution as well. My background has given me cause for this. I am certainly not going to bash these folks as their intent is not for me to judge however I am not a fan of some of the ministries represented here (in video). I believe its dangerous ground when someone says "you cant hear God" or "you're not healed" and the reason they attach to it is "heart being right"... I also do not want to get this thread going in the wrong direction as SK is trying to help us be discerning of the Holy Spirit, whereas (again maybe my history) has shown that many who claim to "hear" God really arent.
|
|
|
Post by disciple4life on Oct 23, 2017 15:53:18 GMT -6
MikeTaft forgive me for this, perhaps my heart isnt right but I am a little skeptical of "healing" ministries or any Word/Faith type. Todd White in the video gives me reason for caution as well. My background has given me cause for this. I am certainly not going to bash these folks as their intent is not for me to judge however I am not a fan of some of the ministries represented here (in video). I believe its dangerous ground when someone says "you cant hear God" or "you're not healed" and the reason they attach to it is "heart being right"... I also do not want to get this thread going in the wrong direction as SK is trying to help us be discerning of the Holy Spirit, whereas (again maybe my history) has shown that many who claim to "hear" God really arent. I agree Mike, - I think you're hitting on a very crucial aspect here - I think it's important truth that can't be understated that God still speaks, in dreams and visions, but no dream or vision rises to the level of divine relevation as scripture. Inspired and Inerrant. The huge issue is balance - The enemy doesn't care which extreme people are in - as long as they are not balanced, he wins. - One extreme is that some people who do indeed have prophetic giftings - ** Yes, all the gifts are alive today for the church - but these people want to make every dream prophetic. Many times a dream is just a dream- It's just talking bunnies, or just all of our co-workers with mullets. Many times, our dreams are the effects of stress, lack of sleep, something we ate, or our minds just playing.
- The other extreme are those who insist with no scriptural evidence at all that some gifts have ceased, and this is usually connected to these gifts being abused - healing, prophecy and tongues are some of the most common. They experienced someone who may have had a prophetic gifting, but 'that' time, it was really what they sincerely thought was God speaking, but later, circumstances showed it was not God speaking. Why, because the event didn't happen, or the person wasn't healed, or there were mistakes.
- The primary way God still speaks to people around the world is through scripture. This is why we are commanded to test/weigh things through scripture and to use discernment and "rightly divide the word of Truth."
In our own lives, now, here in Poland, we have dear friends who are emigrants from a War-torn country. Someone has 'prophesied' that they will move to a specific area in the US near the Beach - "This person had a vision from God." My heart breaks for this couple. Is it possible that this refugee couple could get the 'green card lottery' and get Visa's to move to the US ?? Possible - but in what way does this 'so-called prophesy' build up the church? How does it strengthen their faith?? The very same couple were also led to believe by some pastor that Psalms 103 is the guarantee that God heals everyone - if they just have faith. One verse totally taken out of context. No balance of interpreting other scriptures - cross-referencing. What about Paul? Timothy? All the other people at the Pool of Siloam. ?? As my aunt withered away with Cancer, a man from church prophesied that she would be healed - when she got worse, he simply explained that her faith was weak. Both my aunt and the man have since died of cancer. Someone else - another watchman articulated it very well. "God doesn't do discrepancies." ***Being mistaken doesn't make a person a false prophet - it just means that what they felt was probably heartburn. This is the Balance part. ;-) A real example from a Bible College. An exceptionally handsome young college guy came to enroll at the Bible college - The ladies were smitten. A Godly man, who looked like Captain America. One gal had a dream. She told a close friend that God told her that she would marry this guy. - Another gal had a dream in the next few days, and SHE said that God revealed to her in a dream that she would marry the handsome man. - Then, another gal -- yeah, you guessed it. Really. Within two weeks, four gals all had 'special revelation' by God in a dream that THEY would marry Prince Charming. So which one REALLY heard from God?? As it turns out, Captain Godly was already married, but didn't wear a wedding ring. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- After seeing so many countless examples of Christians who 'heard' from God, or had a vision, and seeing gifts abused, it is my humble opinion that people should never say - "Thus says the Lord, . . ." but rather, say "I'm sensing this in my heart/ spirit and I think it could be from the Holy Spirit, but I could be mistaken - could be indigestion. - Weigh this, and see what you sense? ?" When people emphatically say "God told me such-and-such . . ." then if someone questions it, it puts them/ others in the position of questioning God, and this is where spiritual abuse can occur.
|
|
|
Post by MikeTaft on Oct 23, 2017 16:18:12 GMT -6
Well talk about being pinned in a corner. I wasn't referring to dreams or visions or Todd White's ministry, I was pointing out in their panel that they had an interesting point when it came to healing through the authority of Christ and how sometimes when we attempt to declare healing and nothing happens may be a confidence issue in the power of Christ as we see when the 72 were sent out by Jesus and how one person the disciples failed to heal and were perplexed. Even in the Book of Acts when "the seven" tried casting out a demon in a man and the demon replied "I know Jesus, and I know of Paul, but who are you?" Then the demon possed man beat the crap out of "the seven".
Anyways I see my point was clearly missed and I'll refrain from further commenting on this thread with respect to SK.
|
|
|
Post by mike on Oct 23, 2017 17:59:25 GMT -6
MikeTaft apologies again brother. I simply missed what your point was and took my bias and ran with it. I decided to move the content to open up a dialogue on the subject. Maybe I didn't title properly tho? First you are under no obligation to reply to any of this. We are a bunch that get along pretty well here and with being so familiar with most, I often forget we just met and don't know each other for more than a week, two three... Just to give you a little perspective on my history, I was told for years exactly what D4L spelled out, to the letter. Where I attended they believed in all gifts yet when someone didn't get healed their was sin in their life or their faith was inadequate. So I am overly sensitive to preachers who are of that persuasion and basically have a hard time hearing anything they say. I think D4L has a very similar background. It's most likely that I am justing them unfairly as I am a sinner also. So if you or others have insight or want to discuss this further I want to learn and participate
|
|
|
Post by MikeTaft on Oct 23, 2017 18:26:41 GMT -6
Well thank you for starting a new thread mike . D4L PM'd me and we cleared things up (I think). I'll have to take some time to write out a more in-depth explanation with scripture as to why I have my beliefs. I promised the wife quality time tonight so I'll get back to y'all tomorrow. Love you brothers!
|
|
|
Post by mike on Oct 23, 2017 18:30:04 GMT -6
Priorities, how boring 😂
Enjoy your evening...in fact I hope you don't see this reply until tomorrow
|
|
|
Post by MikeTaft on Oct 24, 2017 7:01:37 GMT -6
Priorities, how boring 😂 Enjoy your evening...in fact I hope you don't see this reply until tomorrow lol. My priorities keep the peace in my home. Hopefully I'll have time to write everything out today. Things are looking to be a busy day at work, and my wife and I are having a large bible study at our house tonight, so I may not be able to finish.
|
|
|
Post by mike on Oct 24, 2017 7:36:02 GMT -6
MikeTaft...no rush! I just wanted a place where we could glean from one another on this topic. I mean you, me and anyone else interested in this subject matter. I have heard both extremes on this and lived through it too. I want to learn other perspectives on it. I will also post up more of my personal experience.
|
|
|
Post by disciple4life on Oct 25, 2017 3:35:10 GMT -6
Well thank you for starting a new thread mike . D4L PM'd me and we cleared things up (I think). I'll have to take some time to write out a more in-depth explanation with scripture as to why I have my beliefs. I promised the wife quality time tonight so I'll get back to y'all tomorrow. Love you brothers! Good job on the priorities. I'm sorry I missed what you wanted to say. They say 80% of everything we communicate is non-verbal, - body language, tone of voice, eye contact, inflection, nodding, - all things that don't come through in a blog or forum. And then there are Otters - Insert long sigh - they make great spinach dip and spiced cider, but God bless em, they often can't say what they mean the first try, or the second. But on the other side, relationships are more important. So let's bust out the Spinach dip, guacamole and hummus.
My point was 95% directed toward rightly dividing the word and the healing was only a side example. Ok, l'll try again. Try to be brief. Balance - as it relates to dividing the word. Truth out of balance -leads to heresy. One of the biggest indicators of heresy is extreme positions. It can be extreme Calvinism or radical Arminianism. One extreme is the love of God- Joel Olsteen, no mention of sin, or repentance. One extreme is on the prophetic side / denominations. Every dream is prophetic, message from God, and every sniffle is a demon and we should just rebuke it. The other extreme are the ones who over-react to gifts abused - and so they go the other extreme. Cessation - the notion that certain gifts - [often called sign gifts- prophecy, healing and tongues] have ceased, are no longer for the church today. Another thought as it relates to dividing the word, and us - watchmen. ;-) This comes from end-times speaker and pastor Steve Cioccolanti. Even his former pastor didn't get everything right. We all have parts of the puzzle, and we study and we learn from others. We stand on the shoulders of those who were before us. Just because a person doesn't have 100% of the answers or details - does not make that person a false prophet. We need to be very careful before applying the Heresy label. This is why I said that in regards to hearing from God -- - The extreme positions are that everything - every dream, is a Word from God, and pulling 33 out of a license plate or Gematria.
- The opposite extreme is that no one hears from God, - all prophetic gifts/ sign gifts have ceased.
Using solid principles of Biblical interpretation - Hermeneutics - has never been more important. In the last days, false prophets will arise, and there will be a great 'apostasy' -turning away from the truth.
|
|
|
Post by MikeTaft on Oct 25, 2017 7:28:23 GMT -6
Here’s my thoughts and understanding when it comes to the power of healing. Many say that these gifts are not available, but I say that the Spirit is the same, with the same power from the beginning of Genesis when He rested over the waters of the earth, to Jesus’ ministry, to present day today. So why does it happen that miracles of healing are rarely seen in the body of Christ today?
Personally, I have experienced healing and seen healing through the power of the Spirit. One testimony, my father-in-law had terrible kidney stones, and when he and the church laid hands on him and prayed over him, and at that moment he said that he felt that kidney stones disappear, as in the pain went away immediately. He hasn’t had kidney stones since. Even though I have yet to walk up to a blind man or someone in a wheel chair and ask them to see or walk (has to do where I am in my walk with Christ) does not mean that the Spirit cannot heal. So again, why do we not see the same miracles performed as when the Apostles and disciples of the early church walked the earth?
Let’s look at some scripture first.
A situation like this occurred when Jesus walked the earth the first time even before the Spirit was given. Let’s read Matthew 17:14-20.
14 And when they were come to the multitude, there came to him a certain man, kneeling down to him, and saying,
15 Lord, have mercy on my son: for he is lunatick, and sore vexed: for ofttimes he falleth into the fire, and oft into the water.
16 And I brought him to thy disciples, and they could not cure him.
17 Then Jesus answered and said, O faithless and perverse generation, how long shall I be with you? how long shall I suffer you? bring him hither to me.
18 And Jesus rebuked the devil; and he departed out of him: and the child was cured from that very hour.
19 Then came the disciples to Jesus apart, and said, Why could not we cast him out?
20 And Jesus said unto them, Because of your unbelief: for verily I say unto you, If ye have faith as a grain of mustard seed, ye shall say unto this mountain, Remove hence to yonder place; and it shall remove; and nothing shall be impossible unto you.
The disciples were sent out healing & casting out demons in the name of Jesus while preaching the kingdom of God is near (Luke 10:1-9). Then they failed to heal a man’s son because of a demon that indwelt inside of him. They were perplexed as to why even though they had so much success beforehand. Jesus clearly stated why, unbelief.
Another situation occurred during Paul’s ministry when some Jewish exorcist attempted to cast out a demon using the name of Jesus illegitimately (Acts 19:13-16). Needless to say, the fact that they didn’t truly believe in Jesus and lacked the Holy Spirit, the demon ripped them to pieces so to speak.
A last example I’d like to use, even though this does not pertain to a “healing” miracle, none the less is still a miracle. In Matthew 14:22-33, Jesus was seen walking on the water in the storm. Jesus told them not to fear, and Peter replied that if it was truly Him, to ask Him to come out to Him on the water. Jesus said “come” and Peter was walking on water to Jesus! It wasn’t until fear crept in and in Peter’s doubt he sank like a rock. He called for Jesus to save him and Jesus did, but he rebuked Him saying, “O thou of little faith, wherefore didst though doubt?” (Matt. 14:31).
From what I understand the disciples were so close to the source of our Lord’s power through miracles, because they saw Him perform them over and over again, that they believed when Jesus told them to do the same, it happened and it reinforced their belief. However, they still struggled with unbelief and failed as we see in the previous verses. In the book of Acts, these same miracles were performed by the Apostles and the disciples without failure. Jesus said to Thomas who doubted His resurrection in John 20:29:
29 Jesus saith unto him, Thomas, because thou hast seen me, thou hast believed: blessed are they that have not seen, and yet have believed.
The first disciples where able to see Jesus and believe, but we today who have not seen Him have an even greater faith and are blessed because of it. So back to my main question, why aren’t we healing miraculously as they did back then? It’s because of unbelief, or more specifically doubt. How often do we pray over someone and have doubt wondering, “I hope the Lord answers my prayer and heals that person.” Even sometimes we go as far to say, “I’m not sure if it will work, but I’ll give it a try.” Is there any confidence in these statements? I’m not talking about confidence in ourselves, but confidence in the Spirit and His ability to do the impossible. In my personal understanding and opinion (with that and two bucks will get you a cup of coffee), it comes down to us having a lack of faith in the Spirit to carry out such a powerful act.
Another thing that may restrict us is the will of our Father. He knows our heart better than we know ourselves. He knows the past present and future of our lives. So sometimes we act in our own attempt to do what we think is right as a Christian without even consulting the Spirit. We have to consult the Spirit whether to move or not when it comes to declaring healing over someone. It is not a matter that should be taken lightly. Nor should we forsake the opportunity when we know full well with confidence that the Spirit is telling us to go over to the person and pray for them and heal them. We today have the same power to heal people today, but we need to have the right heart, with full faith and confidence in the Spirit and acting in accordance with the Father’s will.
Now as D4L mentioned, going to the extremes of personal doctrine can be bad. Zeal for the Lord and pride are two different things. If you try to heal someone and it doesn’t happen, it’s not a matter of “that person is not worthy to be healed,” but rather are you acting in accordance with the Spirit and the will of God? People like to point fingers at others and blame them for the fault, but there’s always more fingers (3 to be exact) pointing right back at you.
I personally will never move to heal someone unless I know and hear specifically from the Spirit to act. Hopefully we can glean something from this matter in SK’s thread “Hearing God”. I hope this explains my position better. Feel free to comment and hopefully by the end of this thread we’ll have a full understanding through the grace of the Holy Spirit who gives us truth.
|
|
|
Post by mike on Oct 25, 2017 8:03:26 GMT -6
D4L - I agree with you and unfortunately due to my prior experience, fall into the cessation group for the most part. Do I believe in miracles and that God heals? Totally. Do I believe God heals everybody because they believe? Nope, not on this side of eternity. Some of my backstory - 20 years ago I had a conversation with a friend and fellow church-go'er. He had some type of cold or something minor. We prayed together and rebuked the devil for attacking him. After a few days (IIRC) he got a little worse as his ears began to hurt. We prayed again and blamed Satan, rebuking him up and down, claiming this healing, quoting that scripture. This was maybe during our mid-week service. By Sunday he came and told me "I went to the doctor. He checked my ears and found out that I had so much wax in there that it was causing pressure and causing me to feel sick. He flushed them out and I was fine a little later". Moral of the story - 1. we have to use our brains that God gave us to discern certain things 2. believe it or not its not always an attack from Satan (although we like to blame him) Now for a more personal note and why I commented on MikeT video the way I did. I'd call it more of a knee jerk though. When I was 4 years it was discovered that my older brother (who was 9) had a brain tumor. It was 1974 and my mom was pregnant with my younger brother. the treated him with chemo and radiation and eventually had to operate. The doctors told my parents he would live more than a year or two. The operation to remove the tumor was successful however given the year of 1974 and techniques, the surgery wasnt without complications. The result was the tumor was gone but the surgery affected his brain and bodily functions. He was left blind in his right eye, partial paralysis in his left leg (leaving him limping) and maybe 50% of his left arm functioning. His cognition also damaged (never really growing beyond that of an 8th grader) & not to mention there was no such thing as bullying back then as we grew up, constantly ridiculed and made fun of. I recall several occasions where the younger had to fist fight for the older. Dont get me wrong, I picked on him and fought with him too, but hey what are brothers for. Now I say all that to set the scene for my response. I thank God for my brother as he was used as the catalyst to lead my mom to Christ! She eventually led my younger brother, sister and myself to the Lord. My dad...another story. Once I came to Christ (1994) I was taught that healing was available for all who believe. If you werent receiving something was wrong on your end of the equation as it was not on God's side (see the ear wax story). I watched my brother go into every healing line, every prayer service people would pray over him, annoint him with oil, everything yet nothing worked. I began to believe that not only did he lack faith to be healed, but thought he may not even be saved. Something had to be wrong with my brother because God doesnt mess up. This doctrine is largely based on Isaiah 53:5 " But he was wounded for our transgressions, he was bruised for our iniquities: the chastisement of our peace was upon him; and with his stripes we are healed." This scripture is often taken out of context as it refers to eternal salvation, not physical healing. Again do it believe God can heal? YES! Does He always? Not on this side of eternity He doesn't. Back to my brother for a moment. As my brother aged his health continued to decline. Around age 14-15 he developed diabetes, age 30 triple bypass, sometime after this a few different "roto-rooter" procedures to clean up scar tissue in his arteries, age 42-46, multiple mini strokes. Due to the stoke events his body continued to decline and his balance became worse than before. About 5-6 years ago when attending a state sponsored work program the person picking him up was helping him walk down stairs and they both fell, with the aid landing on top of him, breaking his collar bone. Happened again, where he broke his left arm, so they decided to put him in a wheel chair to move him around. Then about 4 yrs ago while in the chair the driver failed to lock the chair wheels and he rolled off the lift, backwards hitting his head. He was in ICU for nearly 2 months, yet continued to pull through despite all of this. Why the suffering in his life? Why didnt God heal him? We still don't know. We had all prayed, believed, hoped, prayed more yet nothing. My brothers body eventually failed and he went home to be with the Lord this past January. While we all miss him, our hope is we'll see him again SOON! Saying all of this to provide some backdrop...I am not against the gifts of the Spirit, not at all but when I hear people say something is wrong with the person in need of healing, or their faith isnt strong enough, or there is sin in their life, I get a little upset over it. I was once of that persuation too so I dont throw stones, but I want to point out that when things dont go the way we think they should we need to realize we continue to believe and hope but not blame the person for not being healed. Gods ways are not our ways.
|
|
|
Post by mike on Oct 25, 2017 8:17:27 GMT -6
MikeTaft - it took me almost an hour to write the above response (Interruptions, work-ugh ) so none of that was contemplated regarding your reply. I do want to just touch on the unbelief piece as I'm not certain I fully agree. I am somewhat persuaded by cessasion dispensation. Peter healed many with his shadow: Acts 5:15 Insomuch that they brought forth the sick into the streets, and laid them on beds and couches, that at the least the shadow of Peter passing by might overshadow some of them.Paul with articles of clothing: Acts 19:11 And God wrought special miracles by the hands of Paul: 12 So that from his body were brought unto the sick handkerchiefs or aprons, and the diseases departed from them, and the evil spirits went out of them.yet later on Paul couldn't pray for timothy and heal his ailments? 1 Tim 5:23 Drink no longer water, but use a little wine for thy stomach's sake and thine often infirmities.Nor could the same Paul help Epaphroditus? Philippians 2:25 Yet I supposed it necessary to send to you Epaphroditus, my brother, and companion in labour, and fellowsoldier, but your messenger, and he that ministered to my wants. 26 For he longed after you all, and was full of heaviness, because that ye had heard that he had been sick. 27 For indeed he was sick nigh unto death: but God had mercy on him; and not on him only, but on me also, lest I should have sorrow upon sorrow.Was Paul, Timothy or Epap in unbelief? Why weren't these or others healed?
|
|
|
Post by MikeTaft on Oct 25, 2017 9:07:27 GMT -6
mike - Thank you for the background story, and I grieve with you on the loss of your brother. Thankfully we have the blessed hope of all being together in our restored, resurrected bodies at the end of this age. I'm sure we can all agree you will see your brother healed hopefully in the coming days. You bring some very valid points about Paul. This is why we need all members of the body to function, lol, with all seriousness though this is why I pointed out about making sure we are walking in concordance with the will of our Father. I do not abstain from the the fact that we need full faith, the right heart, and full confidence of the Spirit. I also do not agree that there is something wrong with the person needing healing. However, without proper discernment in the Spirit to act in the will of our Father is not always there. For instance you continually tried everything to heal your brother, but was this what you wanted, or what the Father wanted? His plan is not always our plan, but in this sinful, fallen world He works all things out for our good even if we suffer for it. Would you and your family have been saved if you brother was perfectly healthy? Possibly, but God used him regardless to be a witness to you and your family and that in itself is a great testimony! We are all broken and in need of healing because of our sin. This includes physical ailments as well. But I know without the shadow of a doubt that the power of healing through the help of the Holy Spirit is alive and well today. Whether God allows us to heal others of physical ailments for His purpose or not, it all is used to draw us closer to Him and is for His glory alone. I hope this makes sense.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 25, 2017 13:13:01 GMT -6
I can't tell if this thread is about healing or hearing. And therein lies the answer.
Before there is healing, there is hearing. Without the hearing there is no healing. We say Amen to what God is already saying and the result is healing, casting out of demons, enlightenment, etc.
Denominations that teach Word of Faith concepts, or name it and claim it concepts do not understand the hearing part. They think it is about speaking. They think they can speak things into exists, speak Truth to Power, so to speak. (heh, see what I did there?) They believe that by naming it in the Name of Jesus, it will happen. Their words are meant to bring it about. They fail to recognize that the exact opposite is required. They need to hear. There is only one Word that can bring it about.
Occasionally, they speak something that God is saying and the result is healing, etc. It had nothing to do with their speaking, but what God was speaking.
Not all who are called to these ministries are like this. There are some who hear and say Amen to the Word of the Lord. It is too bad that these are typically not the ones we see on TV.
Yes, we often see people professing words of wisdom, or proclamations, or prophecies of all sorts of things over people. We often have people claiming healing over people. So many words, so few people hearing. Then fellow believers see this - they see the lack of results and make determinations about cessation, dispensation, balance, faith, gifts, etc. Once formed these determinations begin to solidify our belief system and over time, become our doctrines. This is why we must be extreme in our walk of faith. There is no room for balance, no chart to follow, no pattern that plots the course of our journey. The walk of faith is unpredictable and when we start feeling like we have a handle on it, God moves us in a new way to keep it unpredictable.
He fills each of us with the purpose for which he desires us to fulfill. Some for sickness, others for health. It has nothing to do with the amount of faith we have. As a matter of fact, I think a case could be made that sometimes he provides healing for those who don't have the strength of faith to endure sickness. He gives grace when needed. He has mercy upon whom He wishes. His perspective is so much grander than ours.
The root comes back to hearing. And with hearing, we must have discernment (as MT said). We must hear, we must agree, and then we must act upon the voice of God. That's the Ready, Aim, Fire approach. To often we see the Fire, Aim, Ready approach. Or we skip the Ready and Aim altogether.
|
|
|
Post by mike on Oct 25, 2017 14:04:17 GMT -6
@silentknight - well this started out in the (your) "Hearing" thread and I mis-read MikeTaft's intent and felt it best to preserve that thread without getting to a tangent, shifting it all here. Being indoctrinated in "name in and claim it" for many years, its tough to break the old mold. I realize the error there and of course have much to grasp as it pertains to the truth about hearing and as it relates across the board.
|
|