|
Post by venge on Dec 18, 2020 19:06:51 GMT -6
Does the wrath, that we are saved from, happen to be poured out? There are 2 words for wrath in Revelation: Orge and Thumos, but only Thumos is attached to God's wrath being poured out. First, I want to take us back alittle to Daniel:
Now, I dont see anything about God having wrath on man during the AC's time in this verse. It appears that the wrath being poured out comes "at the end which was decreed"...and that end, by the sentence structure above, happens AFTER the midpoint where he sets up the AoD. Even then, the wrath doesnt come. It doesnt happen to the end which would be the end of the latter 3.5 years of that second half.
So does God's wrath, that we are saved from, always happen to be poured out? If it is, we'd look for his wrath and the Day of the Lord to begin at the pouring out. Let's look at some verses.
Here are more: Lamentations 4:11; Jeremiah 6:11; Ezekiel 14:19; Ezekiel 30:15; Psalm 69:24; Ezekiel 7:8; Jeremiah 42:18; Ezekiel 21:31; Ezekiel 22:31; Ezekiel 20:34; 2 Chronicles 12:7; 2 Chronicles 34:25 and there are soo many more
In each case, God's wrath on wicked men is poured out. We find that in ONLY 1 place in Revelation..at the Bowls.
How can God's wrath be any other time if we are shown over and over in scripture it is poured out. That doesnt happen till "the end". These bowls happen after Christ establishes the nations of the world are his (at the 7th trumpet) and he begins to reign. His reign is the millennial Kingdom and that allows Daniel's scripture above to be fulfileld as it is written. With the AC coming to the end of his rule after the last 3.5 years are ended which is when Christ begins to rule.
|
|
|
Post by disciple4life on Feb 27, 2021 13:27:21 GMT -6
Hello my brother. ;-) The question you raise and the verses are really good and it really encourages me and motivates me to study. We both share this passion, along with many fellow watchmen, to really dig deeper and study not only the meaning of specific words, but also the context, and the audience. I appreciate how you are looking at the different possible translations for wrath, and the different occasions where we see this phrase. ;-) I know you know this, it's more for others who are new, or not as well-versed in Bible study, but we have to remember that we as Non-Greek speakers do Bible study backwards. We have to not only look for occurrences of a word or phrase in English, but look at how the English word or phrase may have 3 or 4 different words in the original. Your example of wrath is excellent. What I'm trying to say, is that a person who just does an in-depth word study on wrath is really making a huge mistake. We have to also look at the concept of wrath - what else is it ? In other words, - it's true to say that a big theme of the Tribulation is wrath, but it's equally true to compare this with the larger concept of Judgment. - What does it mean to have one's name written in the book of life? and what does it mean to have it blotted out.?? - What is the significance of the door of heaven opened, and conversely, what does is the significance of the door of heaven to be closed. ?? **Two huge themes that run through the New Testament that most Christians miss. It's at Day of Atonement that the Door is closed and the judgment is meted out, and God makes the judgment for the wicked and his wrath is dispensed. - What do we see - what kinds of words, descriptions -do we see when we study the Day of the Lord?? It's darkness, gloom, calamity, terrible, judgment, punishment and destruction. It's literally the stuff that Hollywood horror films are made of. - Do we see any of these kinds of words that Paul uses in the rapture passages, or the passages of the rapture that Christ uses ? No, we don't. There is a reason, and We should ask ourselves why?? - Why is it that for thousands of years, Christ and John and others use the exact word pictures that have been understood as Omens by Gentiles - horrible signs of terrible things, even as a curse/punishment by Gentiles for thousands of years - the Sun turning black. Does Paul or Christ or John ever use this metaphor with the rapture?? No. - Why is it that Paul, John, Christ, Amos, Daniel, Isaiah, David, Micah, and Gospel writers, all use the same kinds of descriptions when talking about the Day of the Lord- which Jews before Christ, and down through the millennia to the present - understand as the 7 year tribulation, and these same writers, - all use totally different language and descriptions to talk about the rapture?? It's because they are two separate and distinct events, with separate and distinctly different goals and purposes. - It's no accident or coincidence that Christ's first miracle was at a wedding, and that over and over and over Christ used idioms related to wedding and birth, which the audience understood, when He was talking about the rapture.
- It's also clear that over and over, Christ, Paul and John, use the exact same idiom, of the Thief in the Night, - another idiom which was the captain of the Temple guard, - always used in the context of those sleeping, not watching, and the result is punishment, judgment, penalty, destruction.
For the temple guards caught sleeping, they would be beaten and their robes set on fire, - and they threw off their robes, running naked into the courtyard. For the foolish/wicked bridesmaids, - they did not know the hour- [the other 5 did] and the door was shut - [judgment- Day of Atonement] and they were left out of the marriage. Paul makes in unmistakbly clear when he tells the mixed church of Jewish and Gentile believers - that they are NOT children of darkness, but children of the day, so that day will NOT surprise them like a thief in the night. When we look at the whole counsel of scripture and look at the Jewish cultural context of the writers and the audience, it's clear that the rapture and second coming are totally different times and events. Many examples over and over of the righteous being spared, saved, lifted out of harm, calamity and trouble, many of which were warned in advance by an angel, a prophet or God himself. The notion of God subjecting his Bride to tribulation to purify her or punish her is not consistent with scripture. The Bride is lifted up and concealed in the wedding chamber, as David pointed out in Psalms. The Purpose of the Tribulation is the Ultimate Salvation of the Jewish Nation.
|
|
|
Post by venge on Feb 27, 2021 17:19:09 GMT -6
1.
The Day of the Lord is a time of God's wrath, not 7 years of "thlipsis". Thlipsis has nothing to do with Orge or Thumos.
2.
I think the apostles, the early Church, Christians in Brazil, China, North Korea, Sudan and other countries would disagree with you as they continue to go through "thlipsis" today. Even Job, was tried and tested and came forth as gold. The object is not that we all need to be tried (though some do), but to prepare ourselves to be strong when facing temptations. But then, Revelation calls a type of this the "patience of the saints".
3.
I disagree. The purpose of the Day of the Lord is to bring about God's Kingdom on earth, to restore righteousness, to bring about repentance and so much more. The Jew's have been cut off (though they can be re-grafted in)(Romans 11:23). Their house (not God's house)(Luke 13:35) was left desolate.
|
|
|
Post by Natalie on Feb 27, 2021 18:26:11 GMT -6
What do you do with all the promises God made to Israel?
What about Jeremiah 30? Joel 3:1-2? Amos 9:13-15? Is it just part of the "so much more" of Revelation?
What do you do with passages like Hosea 2 (specifically 2:14-23). For He is speaking to Israel. The life of Hosea was a picture of God and Israel. Israel is married to God the Father. There are Scriptures that say this. The Church is promised to God the Son. Yes, currently Jews who put their faith in Messiah are grafted in to be part of the Bride, but God is not talking to the Church in Hosea 2. He is talking to His unfaithful wife, Israel.
They may have been left desolate for a time, but God is not finished with Israel.
|
|
|
Post by venge on Feb 28, 2021 7:09:29 GMT -6
The topic of the thread is the wrath of God. Please feel free to start another thread discussing “Israel”, “Jews” or future inheritance
|
|
|
Post by disciple4life on Feb 28, 2021 11:50:37 GMT -6
Regardless of the broad spectrum of views regarding the timing, - when the wrath is poured out, it certainly affects Jewish people and Israel.
The notion of saying we only want a discussion that doesn't include Jews is as offensive as saying we only want a discussion that doesn't involve Asians or Latinos. The tribulation and wrath affects every non-christian and ethnic group which includes Jews and Israel as much as it includes and affects Chinese and Latinos.
|
|
|
Post by mike on Feb 28, 2021 13:58:46 GMT -6
Regardless of the broad spectrum of views regarding the timing, - when the wrath is poured out, it certainly affects Jewish people and Israel. The notion of saying we only want a discussion that doesn't include Jews is as offensive as saying we only want a discussion that doesn't involve Asians or Latinos. The tribulation and wrath affects every non-christian and ethnic group which includes Jews and Israel as much as it includes and affects Chinese and Latinos. Timing is certainly important. Saying the tribulation or wrath is specific and exclusive to ethnic Jews and unsaved gentiles, excludes the idea that there will be any believers remaining. Since there is no solid proof of any until after it happens, we cant speak in terms of 100% certainty. With this possibility in mind, it isnt offensive. Some believe that the church will experience some, much or most of the final 3.5 years. From this perspective no one should be singled out
|
|
|
Post by venge on Feb 28, 2021 15:53:34 GMT -6
Regardless of the broad spectrum of views regarding the timing, - when the wrath is poured out, it certainly affects Jewish people and Israel. The notion of saying we only want a discussion that doesn't include Jews is as offensive as saying we only want a discussion that doesn't involve Asians or Latinos. The tribulation and wrath affects every non-christian and ethnic group which includes Jews and Israel as much as it includes and affects Chinese and Latinos. Timing is certainly important. Saying the tribulation or wrath is specific and exclusive to ethnic Jews and unsaved gentiles, excludes the idea that there will be any believers remaining. Since there is no solid proof of any until after it happens, we cant speak in terms of 100% certainty. With this possibility in mind, it isnt offensive. Some believe that the church will experience some, much or most of the final 3.5 years. From this perspective no one should be singled out Agreed mike ,. Believers in any time period (history or future) are part of the body of Christ. That includes believers during "Orge" after the 6th seal. Christ said we will always have "thlipsis". For others, I wanted to address this: It is the same word :thlipsis that is used in Matthew 24:21 We are NEVER saved from tribulation (thlipsis). We go through it, endure it and conquer it as Christ has. "Orge" and "Thumos" is the context. So when someone says "tribulation", it is unscriptural that we are to avoid it as Christians. We are never promised that nor are we promised that it lasts 7 years, its equated with God's wrath or that a rapture happens before any "thlipsis". Tribulation and the flood are not the same context. This is why it is important to study the actual words used to avoid making mistakes like the above. Why did John use 2 different words for God's wrath in Revelation but to make a distinction between his wrath poured out and his judgment. His flaring up and his controlled temper. His precise judgment vs a wide judgment. Why allow people to be witnessed to (by the 2 witnesses), hoping they repent and be changed during "Orge" and not "Thumos"? Why does it matter who takes the mark if this is God's wrath and they all have no hope? Obviously, John wanted us to look at other scripture and see and not to make conflated judgments of our own such as has been done in some Churches today.
|
|
|
Post by Natalie on Feb 28, 2021 16:23:54 GMT -6
Our view of the nation of Israel and the Church will influence how we interpret end times events.
I'm bowing out of the discussion. I have stated my position on this other places. Venge and I disagree, and I am going to leave it at that.
|
|
|
Post by venge on Feb 28, 2021 20:09:43 GMT -6
Our view of the nation of Israel and the Church will influence how we interpret end times events. I'm bowing out of the discussion. I have stated my position on this other places. Venge and I disagree, and I am going to leave it at that. The discussion is on God’s wrath, the words used, why John used both, and is counter to tribulation. This particular discussion is not meant to address physical or spiritual Israel. Noah was saved from the flood (wrath) the same day he entered the ark. What type of wrath was this? Is this wrath the same language as Sodom, Babylon or others? In all these cases, how long did God’s wrath last? Days, weeks or years? Did OT prophets and Jews go through wrath without experiencing wrath? These are questions we aught to understand.
|
|
|
Post by disciple4life on Feb 28, 2021 20:49:36 GMT -6
"Our view of the nation of Israel and the Church will influence how we interpret end times events. I'm bowing out of the discussion. I have stated my position on this other places. Venge and I disagree, and I am going to leave it at that." Well said, Natalie. I will do the same.
|
|
|
Post by venge on Mar 1, 2021 7:42:13 GMT -6
"Our view of the nation of Israel and the Church will influence how we interpret end times events. I'm bowing out of the discussion. I have stated my position on this other places. Venge and I disagree, and I am going to leave it at that." Well said, Natalie . I will do the same. Sadly, the topic here is not meant to address those things. I am not sure why people are pushing for it. Unless you don't agree with definitions of wrath and that interferes with your end times theory? In this case, I think 1 Thess 5:9-10 speaks for itself. or 1 Thess 1:10 In both examples, this wrath is "Orge", not "thlipsis" (tribulation). If we are to use these 2 verses as the reason we are to escape wrath and to be raptured...it is impossible to say it is Pre-Tribulation. That is, not the theory itself, but the title of the theory. What about Romans 5:9 Like the 2 examples above, this also uses "Orge". So, I suppose my question is why do many churches still say we escape tribulation? My own Church does this. God's wrath isnt inflicted upon us daily. If it becomes wide spread, encompassing multiple nations, that still doesnt make it God's wrath. Is there anything else that constitutes God's wrath besides a word like "Orge" or "Thumos"?
|
|
|
Post by boraddict on Mar 1, 2021 8:54:21 GMT -6
So, there are personal difficulties that occur in our daily lives, and there is tribulation that comes from someone like Hitler in WWII. There is also wrath that comes from God that is more than the normal daily life difficulties and more than a tribulation from Hitler types.
1) personal life difficulties 2) tribulation caused by wicked and evil leaders 3) wrath of God that is complete destruction upon the wicked
Clearly the saints do not go through a wrath of God that is upon the wicked; or, if they do go through it they are protected. However, they might go through a tribulation caused by wicked and evil leaders just as was done in WWII where the destruction upon the Jewish people was horrific.
So if we look at WWII as a type; there were in the beginning the normal life struggles. Then some wicked and evil leaders arose to cause a tribulation. Lastly, the wrath of God came upon those wicked and evil leaders and their people via destruction. Germany got a real spanking for what they did.
In this third and final world war we have the normal life's struggles with the covid. Next will arise wicked and evil leaders to cause a tribulation. Lastly will be the wrath of God.
It all seems to be a natural set of occurrences that befall the human condition. We could however as a society choose to reject the wicked and evil leaders. Then the pattern would be something like normal difficulties leading to good leaders to solve the problems. No tribulation from wicked leaders and no wrath of God.
|
|
|
Post by mike on Mar 1, 2021 9:01:52 GMT -6
venge As you may know I am reading/studying Isaiah. ebrah: overflow, arrogance, fury Original Word: עֶבְרָה Part of Speech: Noun Feminine Transliteration: ebrah Phonetic Spelling: (eb-raw') Definition: overflow, arrogance, fury This word ebrah is also used in Job 40:11 (among other places) and considered 'an outburst of anger'. Are you differentiating Orge and Thumos in a similar manner where wrath is very sudden, extreme yet short and quick (Thumos) and wrath as an outpouring where is slower and less severe (Orge)?
|
|
|
Post by venge on Mar 1, 2021 9:25:30 GMT -6
Yes, I am. Short and sweet lol
I would say outpoured wrath is suited to NT Thumos
Seems like that wrath above is not to extinguish, but to punish. I’d have to look at other uses of it in scripture
|
|